The christians gave up on life they thought it was the end of the world while on the other hand the muslims thought it was a blessing for their sins both christians and muslims are human and. As in christian europe, muslims believed that god's will caused the plague but muslim religious scholars taught that the plague was a martyrdom and mercy from god, assuring the believer's place in paradise. During black death, the christians were blaming the jews for poisoning the wells and for being the cause for black death they assumed this was true just because the jews were least affected by the plague. 1 nytimes article review: find an article from the nytimes website that interests you and deals with global topics write the report here are a few good suggestions: iraq suffers as the euphrates river dwindles rights campaigner in chechnya killed toy factory melee set off western china violence us opens path to asylum for victims.
Not only did the responses of the christians and the muslims differentiate by the way they responded to the plague, but also the non-religious causes while the christians thought of it as a punishment from the holy god, the muslims found it as a gift from god himself. During the era of the black plague, the christian community held a lood-thirsty lead hand in the fact of the matter, while the islam society didn't blame the epidemic on others and or try to solve the rampant disease with violence. Dbq - black death: how different were christian and muslim responses in your course notebook, define each of the following terms you do not need to write sentences for these. Abstract the past decade has seen the publications of numerous excellent studies on the black death for the most part, however, scholars have been preoccupied with debating whether the black death was caused by plague or not, parallels between the first, second, and third plague pandemics, and broader historiographical questions of continuity and change.
I know the christians believed the black death was a punishment from god for their sins and thought that the world was ending a group of christian men called the flagellant brothers tried to stop the disease by whipping their bodies to punish themselves. The infamous plague, known as the black death, was a deadly disease which managed to spread throughout europe and the middle east in the 14th century although both the europeans and the empires of islam experienced the black death, each region had different responses and reasons for the causes of. The muslims and the christians had very opposite views and reactions to the plague while one group stuck to its religion the other turn away from theirs and became like the people of the world the christians was the ones to turn away from their religion and become like everyone else.
Because the physicians blamed the black death on an evil, polluted fog, logical recommendations to prevent the fever involved avoiding these miasmas, or corruptions of air many medieval tracts address how to avoid sickness, but we know very little about how medieval doctors tried to cure the. Islam and christianity, although sharing many similarities, also had their fair share of disagreements, one being their responses to the black death the religion, demography, and interactions all contributed to the differentiation of muslim and christian reactions. Michael w dols, the comparative communal responses to the black death in muslim and christian societies, viator 5, (january 1974) discusses mainly non-medical responses to the plague both in europe and the middle east. Historical research and study: the black death the image below shows a page from a medical textbook published in 1555 the text claims bloodletting is a good treatment for the plague and cured some cases.
Responses that christians made were much different from muslims during the bubonic plague william dene described christians as being in such pandemonium that the labourers and skilled workingmans were imbued with such a spirit of rebellion that neither male monarch jurisprudence nor justness would control them. Another way that christian responses were different from muslims was the ideas of the causes behind the disease that was plaguing them gabrielle de mussis stated in his writing we know that whatever we suffer is the just reward of our sins (doc 4a) christians thought that their sins were the cause behind the plague. Unlike the christians, the muslims hadn't been killing random people because they had the plague, mostly because people were dying quickly from the plague but in the end, they couldn't take it anymore, so the muslims started praying against the black death with the christians and the jews. The black death: how different were the christian and muslim responses in the year of 1348, the black death broke out as a great pandemic that affected much of eurasia a large part of the influence on the reactions of the people living in this era came from religion.
The black death: how different were christian and muslim responses the aztecs: what should history say what was the most important consequence of the printing press. what were the different responses between christian and muslims towards the black plague well the black plague was a highly contagious disease it spread through the 13th century killing 80116000 people. The black death arrived on european shores in 1348 by 1350, the year it retreated, it had felled a quarter to half of the region's population in 1362, 1368, and 1381, it struck again—as it would periodically well into the 18th century.
Best answer: the black death did not decimate the muslim population it took 60% of the european population, and hardly a quarter of that for the middle east and north africa it took 60% of the european population, and hardly a quarter of that for the middle east and north africa. Christians, muslims, and jews confront the plague the black death was a terrible natural disaster that killed one to two thirds of europe's populations, though despite its geographical reach - from central asia through the mid- dle east to scandinavia - it was by far not a universal disaster in that many areas within this region were, at. In the middle of the fourteenth century a devastating andemic of plague, commonly known in european history as the black death, swept through the entire mediterranean world 1 this cataclysmic event caused a dramatic demographic decline in muslim and christian countries and provoked definable communal responses 2. While christians in europe saw the plague as the just reward of our sins, muslims in the middle-east accepted the plague as a blessing from god as you can see, the muslim and christian faiths both had some similarities and differences in how they reacted to the great pestilence.